When a shiny Lexus SUV was spotted on CARFAX, a couple from Doylestown, Pennsylvania, believed they had found a trustworthy deal. The vehicle was priced at $46,000 and associated with Specialty Auto, a dealership located in Lincoln, Nebraska. Although the distance of 1,400 miles raised some concerns for them, they reached out to the contact number provided on the website.
On the other end of the line was a man claiming to be the owner, Jim Woods. Initially, he seemed legitimate, skillfully addressing their concerns and providing reassurance. Adrianna Parsons, one of the individuals involved, reflected on their experience, stating, “He played the role. He preyed on us. My gut was telling me to stop, but I didn’t listen to it well enough.” Despite her nagging instincts, the couple was convinced and decided to wire $45,000 to secure the vehicle.
Unfortunately, the SUV never arrived. The truth was that the man they spoke to was not the genuine Jim Woods, and the dealership’s website was a facade. The real Jim Woods has reported that he does not sell cars online and maintains no internet presence, and he has since been contacted by other victims of similar scams.
Understanding Dealership Cloning
The deception that ensnared the Parsons couple is a form of sophisticated fraud known as dealership cloning. In this scheme, scammers meticulously replicate the name, location, and employee details of legitimate dealerships to create convincing fake online presences. These fraudsters often generate falsified vehicle listings on platforms like CARFAX, Facebook Marketplace, or Craigslist, using stolen images and real Vehicle Identification Numbers (VINs) to make their scams seem more credible.
While CARFAX is generally considered a trusted resource for vehicle history information, it is not free from fraudulent listings. When approached for comments, the company opted not to disclose their methods for vetting dealer listings. However, they did acknowledge, “If CARFAX is made aware of a potentially fraudulent listing, the team acts swiftly to investigate and remove it.”
Since the reports surfaced, the fraudulent Specialty Auto website has been shut down, and local law enforcement along with the Nebraska DMV are currently investigating the incident. The FBI has also been notified of the situation. Despite these steps, Parsons highlighted that the financial consequences of the scam were “cataclysmic” for her family.
Protecting Yourself from Dealership Cloning Scams
As online car sales become increasingly popular, so too do the risks associated with them. To ensure your safety when engaging in online vehicle transactions, consider the following precautions:
-
Verify the Seller: Always check the dealership’s website URL and make a phone call to the dealership directly. Be cautious of any discrepancies in contact information, subtle misspellings, or prices that seem too good to be true. Conducting a search on the dealership’s name alongside terms like “scam” or “fraud” may reveal any complaints or issues tied to them.
-
Avoid Risky Payments: It’s crucial never to wire money, use gift cards, or send cryptocurrency for vehicle purchases. Instead, consider payment methods that offer more security, such as using a credit card or a reputable escrow service that holds funds until the vehicle is delivered and verified.
-
Get Proof of the Car: Request a custom video from the seller that clearly demonstrates they possess the vehicle in question. Additionally, independently ordering a VIN report and cross-referencing it with images and seller information can help verify the legitimacy of the offer. If purchasing remotely, hiring an independent mechanic to conduct a thorough inspection of the vehicle can serve as another layer of protection.
-
Trust Your Instincts: If a deal appears too good to be true, it probably is. In the case of the Parsons, her instinct told her to proceed with caution, but the scammer managed to instill doubt that led her to go against her better judgment.
As more reputable dealerships transition their operations online, it becomes increasingly important for consumers to thoroughly vet potential sellers and recognize signs of possible scams. Taking these precautions can help prevent becoming a victim of dealership cloning and other fraudulent schemes.
Conclusion
This article serves to provide insights and information regarding dealership cloning and scams in the automotive market. It is meant to inform consumers of potential dangers in the online marketplace and help them make informed decisions.
